Skip to content
the Giving Review

the Giving Review

Independent analysis of and commentary about philanthropy and giving Co-edited by William A. Schambra, Daniel P. Schmidt, and Michael E. Hartmann

search icon
share toggle Share
Menu nav toggle

democracy

(Wikimedia Commons)

Understanding Trump’s victory: philanthropy played a role, but not in the way it intended

William A. Schambra

Philanthropy is uniquely unsuited for involvement in American politics. Indeed, what it considers its political strengths turn out to be serious liabilities. Nothing demonstrates this better than its role in the 2024 presidential election.

Full Article
14Nov2024

When nonprofits subvert democracy

Michael E. Hartmann & William A. Schambra

Donors privileged over the democratic electorate.

Full Article
28Oct2024
N. S. Lyons

A conversation with The Upheaval’s N. S. Lyons (Part 1 of 2)

Michael E. Hartmann & Daniel P. Schmidt

The Substack writer talks to Michael E. Hartmann and Daniel P. Schmidt about his newsletter, Gnosticism, progressive managerialism, the Ford Foundation, philanthropy’s role in the ideological revolution, and what could perhaps be done about it.

Full Article
3Sep2024

Thoughts on philanthropy from books featured in The Giving Review in first half of 2024

The GR Editors

A mid-year collection of interesting and insightful passages.

Full Article
1Aug2024
(Wikimedia Commons)

Philanthropy, The Hammer, and the open question

Michael E. Hartmann

Labor journalist Hamilton Nolan’s new book on “the struggle for the soul of labor” takes progressive philanthropy to task for not prioritizing the promotion of America’s labor movement and makes an urgent plea for it to do more, and with more patience.

Full Article
26Feb2024

“Democracy funders” lopsidedly liberal

Michael Watson

As tracked by Candid, of top 200 givers, 121 are left-of-center and 21 are right-of-center. All but two of top 20 are left-leaning.

Full Article
2May2022

The strained relationship between philanthropy and American democracy, and its causes

William A. Schambra

And where to look for rebuilding self-governance.

Full Article
6Sep2019
More Articles
  • About
  • Collections
  • Conversations
  • Current
  • Opinion
  • Reviews
  • Contact
© The Giving Review. All rights reserved.
  • About
  • Collections
  • Conversations
  • Current
  • Opinion
  • Reviews
  • Contact